Moving to Florida: how to prove it
New York and California audit people who leave, and the person who moved has to prove it. The audit comes years later and is won or lost on records: where you were each day, and where your life really is. We keep those records every month, so the answer is ready if an auditor ever asks.
days is the line in New York.
Keep a home there and spend more than 183 days in the state, and New York taxes you as a resident, even with a Florida driver's license. Any part of a day counts as a full day.
Two tests, and you have to pass both
The day count
New York counts every day you spend any part of in the state. Land at JFK at 11 p.m. and that is a New York day. If you still keep a home in New York and the count passes 183, you are a New York resident for the year, wherever you say you live. California presumes you are a resident if you spend more than nine months of the year there.
Where home really is
Even under 183 days, the auditor asks where your home is. New York looks at five things: your homes and how you use them, your active business ties, where you spend your time, where your "near and dear" items are (family photos, art, heirlooms, pets), and where your family lives. California weighs where your closest connections are.
We keep the record every month
We walk through the Florida steps with you and your attorney: the Declaration of Domicile, homestead exemption, driver's license, voter registration and car registration. We set up a residency app on your phone with read-only access for us.
We import the phone's day log and check it against your card charges, bank activity and tolls. A New York charge on a Florida day gets explained while it's fresh, not years later.
You see a running count of days in each state, with a warning at 120 and again at 150 New York days, so you can plan the fall.
We deliver the evidence file: the full-year day calendar with the source for each day, the domicile checklist with documents, and a plain-English summary for you and your attorney.
What the year-end file shows
- Every day of the year, the state you were in, and the records behind it
- Days in New York (or California) against the limit
- Florida driver's license, voter registration and car registration
- Homestead exemption and the Declaration of Domicile
- Florida doctors, dentists and pharmacies
- Where the safe deposit box, pets, art and heirlooms are
- Clubs, houses of worship and charities in Florida
- Business ties: where you work, and what you still do in the old state
Each item carries a date and the document behind it. The summary explains both tests in plain English before it shows the numbers, so the reader understands what the record proves.
Flat fees, quoted before we start
Every fee is agreed up front in an engagement letter. It never depends on your income or on how much tax is at stake.
The annual residency file
- Monthly day tracking from your phone's day log
- Checked against your cards, bank activity and tolls
- A running count by state, with warnings at 120 and 150 days
- The year-end evidence file and plain-English summary
- Reviewed and signed off by a U.S. CPA
| Service | Fee |
|---|---|
| Move-year setup: the domicile checklist, the Florida steps, the app set up, and the first evidence file | $3,500 one time |
| Add-ons, when they apply | Fee |
| A home kept in New York or California | $1,500 a year |
| Each additional family member tracked | $1,000 a year |
| Rebuilding a past year from records | $2,500 per year |
| Records for your attorney during an audit | Quoted per audit |
| Family office clients | Included |
Common questions
When should we start?
In the year you move, ideally before it. The first year after a move is the one auditors look at hardest, and a record kept from the first day is the strongest one you can have.
Is the phone app enough on its own?
No, and auditors know it. A phone log is believed when the card charges, tolls and travel records tell the same story. That is why we check one against the other every month, and why we ask for every phone, card and account you use.
Do you help us plan around the 183 days?
We show you the count all year so you are never surprised. We report where you were, with the records behind each day. We don't help anyone appear to be somewhere they weren't, and the file is only as good as the records you give us.
Who handles the audit if one comes?
Your attorney represents you. We give the attorney the evidence file and the schedules, and we answer the auditor's records requests. Most of the work an audit demands is already done.
We moved two years ago and didn't track. Is it too late?
No. We can rebuild past years from card statements, phone records, tolls and travel. It takes more work than tracking as you go, so it is priced per year rebuilt, and we start tracking the current year right away.
Do you work with our advisors in New York?
Yes. We work alongside your attorney, wealth advisor and the accountant who prepares your returns, and we send them the file each year.
Wealth advisors and attorneys: share the guide with every client who is moving south, and ask us for the sample residency evidence file.
Talk with us about your move
Tell us where you are moving from, what you are keeping there, and who else is moving with you. We will tell you what the record needs and quote the fee before any work begins. Wealth advisors and attorneys are welcome to call on a client's behalf.
Baratelli CPA & Accounting, PLLC
700 S Rosemary Avenue, Suite 204, West Palm Beach, Florida 33401