THE BARATELLI INSTITUTE · Mentoring at Scale
SBC VALUATION SUITE · THE FRAMEWORK NOBODY ELSE OPERATIONALIZES

Stop conflating GAAP SBC expense with real economic dilution.

Every public-company analyst treats stock-based compensation as a single number that hits the income statement and dilutes the share count. That framing is wrong. Out-of-the-money options are phantom dilutionthey generate GAAP expense but will likely never be exercised. RSUs and ITM options are real future dilutionthey vest and convert to shares regardless of price. Buybacks offsetcash spent retiring shares reduces actual share count. This tool sorts your company's SBC into those three buckets and tells you what the real share-count change is.

Bucket sort
Phantom / Real / Offset
ITM vs OTM
Option moneyness flag
Net Δshares
After buyback
GAAP vs real
$ SBC vs share dilution
Try the worked example. Lyft FY2025: 0 options outstanding, 26.3M RSUs/PSUs, 30.3M shares bought back, $322M GAAP SBC expense. Result: net share count declined 12Meven with a third of a billion in SBC expense. Click to auto-fill.

Position disclosure. The author owns shares of LYFT. Lyft is used here as a worked example because its FY2025 filing illustrates the phantom-dilution point unusually cleanly, not as a comment on the security. Educational tool, not investment advice, not a research report, not a buy/sell rating, not a price target. Every input traces to a public SEC filing. The Institute is not a registered investment adviser; this is a Lowe v. SEC publisher-exception publication.

STAGE 1 OF 4

Current stock price and options outstanding

From the most recent 10-K stock-compensation footnote: the weighted-average exercise price of options outstanding and the option count.

$
Recent close, or the price you want to evaluate moneyness against.
$
From the 10-K SBC footnote: the "weighted-average exercise price" of options outstanding.
Total option count from the 10-K rollforward. For mature companies this is often near zero (RSUs replaced options ~2015 onward).
STAGE 2 OF 4

RSUs and PSUs outstanding

RSUs (and PSUs at target) convert to shares regardless of stock price. They are real future dilution.

From the 10-K equity-award rollforward: unvested RSUs and PSUs combined. PSUs at target unless company discloses otherwise.
STAGE 3 OF 4

Recent buyback and GAAP SBC expense

Shares actually retired in the most recent fiscal year. From the cash flow statement "Repurchases of common stock" / weighted-average price.
Total stock-based compensation expense recognized for the year, from the cash flow statement.
STAGE 4 OF 4

Reality check: what your SBC actually dilutes

WANT THE METHODOLOGY BEHIND THIS TOOL?
Read more in the CFO Guide.
The tool gives you the answer. The guide gives you the argumentthe case law, the worked examples, the negotiation playbook, the cross-check tables, the exception cases.
The methodology behind this calculator is in Ch 19 Stock-Based Compensation (Reality Check) of the reference guide.
Read more in the CFO Guide → Browse all 47 guides
Educational references and tools, not legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice, and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consult a qualified professional about your specific situation. © 2026 The Baratelli Institute.

Investing: Pick the level that fits

Same subject. Four levels of depth.

Same practitioner voice at every tier: from the free compounding engine to the CFO reference.