BARATELLIOne firm. One platform. Every market.
BARATELLI TRANSACTION ADVISORY, LLC

Quality of earnings

An independent analysis of a business's earnings: every add-back tested against the general ledger, bank receipts and disbursements reconciled to the books and the tax returns, and the earnings a lender can carry into debt service coverage, with the support for each number attached.

The ten quality of earnings procedures video

▶ Watch the 72-second video of the ten QoE procedures →

A seller's recast (the seller's own adjusted earnings schedule) is an assertion. A quality of earnings is that assertion tested, line by line, against the records that would exist whether or not anyone was selling: the ledger, the bank statements, the payroll reports, the Forms W-3 and the agings. Where an add-back is supported, the report says what supports it. Where it is not, the report says so and removes it.

A fixed fee, set by the scope and quoted in writing before any work starts. Half on signing the engagement letter, half on delivery of the report, and the fee never depends on whether the transaction closes or on what the report finds. The schedule is set in the engagement letter and depends on how quickly the documents arrive; we do not shorten testing to meet a closing date. Every report is signed by Philip A. Baratelli, Owner, Baratelli Transaction Advisory, LLC.

How the fee works What actually gets tested What SOP 50 10 8.1 requires Ask for the sample report
See the work

Open a real sample

The report and the request list, as the buyer and the bank receive them. Sample data; every name is invented.

A quality of earnings report
A nine-page sample report on the Delta Fastener acquisition: the answer on page one, every finding, the cash proof and the SBA section.
Open the PDF →
The QoE request list
Every document a quality of earnings asks for, grouped by subject.
Open the page →
Fixed
Set by the scope and quoted in writing before any work starts: never contingent on the closing or the finding
Agreed
Schedule set in the engagement letter, from complete information: testing is never shortened to meet a closing date
TTM + 2
Cash proof of receipts and disbursements: the trailing twelve months and the last two fiscal years
Signed
Every report signed by Philip A. Baratelli, Owner, Baratelli Transaction Advisory, LLC
The requirement

What SOP 50 10 8.1 now asks a lender for

SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, published September 25, 2026 and in force since October 1, 2026: for an Initial Acquisition or Business Expansion with a Business Purchase Price of $3 million or more, the lender must obtain a quality of earnings in addition to the business valuation (Appendix 15, C.1.i). The threshold is measured before buyer equity, seller debt or other financing, and the Business Purchase Price excludes owner-occupied commercial real estate: the lender removes its appraised value from the contract price (A.15, A.15.a). Owner Buyout and ESOP & Cooperative transactions are not subject to the requirement. The QoE must be performed by an independent, experienced financial professional for the benefit of the lender and must not be prepared by or for the seller; a QoE the buyer commissioned may be used only after one of the lender’s approved vendors reviews it (C.1.i). It must include a cash proof that reconciles bank receipts and disbursements to the income statement and the tax return for the trailing twelve months and the last two fiscal years (C.1.i.b), and the lender must use the QoE earnings in the debt service coverage (A.16.a, C.1.i.d).
From SOP 50 10 8.1 (published September 25, 2026; effective October 1, 2026), Appendix 15, paragraphs A.15, A.16 and C.1.i. Both dates are stated because the SOP is revised: verify the current text for any specific file.

Three phrases in that paragraph do the work. Independent rules out the company's own accountant and anyone whose fee moves with the outcome. For the benefit of the lender rules out the report the seller already has, however good it is, and a seller frequently does already have one, which is the most common surprise on these files; a report the buyer commissioned can be used only after the lender's vendor reviews it. And cash proof rules out a recast built from the income statement alone: bank receipts and disbursements have to be reconciled to the income statement and the tax return for the trailing twelve months and each of the two fiscal years before it, which is the single procedure a thin report most often omits.

The consequence for the file is that the earnings figure in front of credit has to come from a report conducted for the lender’s benefit, and the lender carries that figure into the debt service coverage. The desk at Baratelli Transaction Advisory, LLC also reads eligibility, size, use of proceeds and the change-of-ownership conditions against the SOP as a separate engagement, so the exceptions on a file can be named before it reaches committee.

Three engagements, and they are not interchangeable

Who ordered the report changes what it is for

Lender-ordered QoE

The report SOP 50 10 8.1 requires on an Initial Acquisition or Business Expansion with a Business Purchase Price of $3 million or more. A cash proof of receipts and disbursements for the trailing twelve months and the last two fiscal years, every seller add-back tested against the ledger, wages tied to Forms W-3, and the earnings the lender uses in the debt service coverage. Conducted for the benefit of the lender, independent of the buyer, the seller and the company.

Ordered by
The lender. A report prepared by or for the seller does not qualify, and one the buyer commissioned needs the lender’s vendor review first
Deliverable
Report and Excel workbook with live formulas; the signed management representation letter is kept on file
Fee
Fixed, set by the scope and quoted in writing before work begins

Buy-side QoE

The earnings behind the price, before signing. Add-backs tested rather than accepted, receipts and disbursements reconciled to the bank statements, working capital measured against a normal level rather than against the closing balance, and the debt-like items the price should carry identified while there is still a negotiation to have. A buyer who learns in month three what a report would have said in week two has paid for the information twice.

Ordered by
The buyer, or the buyer's advisor
Schedule
Set in the engagement letter; it depends on how quickly the documents arrive
Free reading first
Due Diligence: What to Check

Sell-side QoE

A quality of earnings the seller commissions before going to market. Stated plainly: it does not satisfy the lender's requirement, because SOP 50 10 8.1 bars a report prepared by or for the seller (Appendix 15, C.1.i), and nobody should buy it believing otherwise. What it does is find the issues while there is still time to fix them, which is the difference between a price adjustment at closing and a clean file at launch.

Ordered by
The seller, or the broker or advisor taking it to market
Start free
The sale readiness check runs the same tests on your own books, free
Then read
What the sale process looks like
The work itself

What actually gets tested

The organizing principle is that nothing is accepted because it appeared in a summary. Every figure that survives into the report is a figure traced to a document that exists for a reason other than this transaction: a bank statement, a filed payroll return, an aging the company runs to collect money.

ProcedureWhat it is, and why it matters
Is the revenue real
Cash proof (proof of cash)Bank receipts and disbursements reconciled to the income statement and the tax return for the trailing twelve months and each of the last two fiscal years. This is the procedure SOP 50 10 8.1 names (Appendix 15, C.1.i.b), and it is the one that catches revenue the books record and the bank never saw, and expenses the books never recorded.
Revenue traced to depositsRecorded revenue tied back to money that actually arrived, period by period, with the differences explained rather than netted.
Year-end cut-offWhether revenue and expenses landed in the period they belong to, or were moved across a year-end to shape a trend.
Are the add-backs real
Every seller add-back testedEach one tested against the general ledger rather than accepted from the recast. An add-back that cannot be located in the ledger does not survive into the earnings figure.
Personal chargesOwner expenses run through the business: identified, quantified and either added back with support or left where they are.
Manual entriesJournal entries made by hand rather than generated by a transaction, which is where a figure gets adjusted without a document behind it.
Wages against Forms W-3Payroll in the books reconciled to the payroll actually filed. A wage add-back that disagrees with the W-3 is the most common defect in a seller recast.
What the price should carry
Customer concentrationMeasured, not characterized. A business where two customers are most of the revenue is a different credit from one where fifty are, at the same earnings.
Working capitalMeasured against a normal level rather than the closing balance, which is what determines whether the buyer is funding the business or funding a hole on day one. The report shows the monthly figure for the trailing twelve months and its average; it does not propose a peg, which the buyer and the seller negotiate.
Debt-like itemsDeferred revenue, accrued but unpaid obligations, capital leases and the rest: the items that behave like debt in the price even when they are not called debt on the balance sheet.

This list is the standing scope. The engagement letter names the procedures performed on a specific file, and a procedure not listed in that letter was not performed: see the scope section below.

What arrives

Two deliverables, and the representation letter on file

The report

The earnings figure, the bridge from the reported figure to it, every adjustment with the document it rests on, the exceptions found, and the items the price should carry. Written to be read by a credit committee rather than by another accountant.

The Excel workbook

Live formulas, not a printout pasted into a grid. A lender can re-run coverage at its own terms, a buyer can test a different price, and either can see which inputs the conclusion is sensitive to without asking for a revision.

The management representation letter

Signed by the company and kept on file with the engagement. It records what management asserted, which is what makes it visible later which figures rested on an assertion rather than on a document.

Every report is signed by Philip A. Baratelli, Owner, Baratelli Transaction Advisory, LLC, before it is delivered.

Fee and schedule

A fixed fee, quoted in writing before anything is signed

TermWhat it isWhere it is fixed
FeeFixed, set by the scope: the number of entities and periods, the condition of the records and the document list. Never a percentage of the priceQuoted in writing before work starts
PaymentHalf on signing the engagement letter, half on delivery of the report. Never contingent on the deal closing or on what the report findsThe engagement letter
ScheduleDepends on how quickly the documents arrive. Testing is not shortened to meet a closing dateThe engagement letter
How it works

Four steps, and the intake list drives the schedule

1 · Engage

The client signs an engagement letter. It names who engaged this desk, confirms independence from the buyer, the seller and the company in writing, fixes the fee and the schedule, and states the scope, including the non-attest character of the work.

2 · Intake

The company uploads through a private, encrypted link. Any accounting system works. Owners keeping books in Baratelli Bankable send the whole set in one click.

3 · Testing

The procedures above, run against the source documents. Questions go back in one consolidated list rather than one at a time, because a company answering a trickle of emails is a company whose file takes three months.

4 · Report

Philip A. Baratelli signs the report as owner of Baratelli Transaction Advisory, LLC. The report and the workbook are delivered together, and the signed representation letter is kept on file.

The intake list: what “complete information” means

The schedule in the engagement letter runs from the day the last of these arrives. The company supplies thirteen items; the IRS transcripts come through the lender, and management interviews are conversations, not files. The list is published here rather than sent after signing so that a lender, a buyer or a broker can tell in advance whether a company is in a position to be tested at all, which is frequently the real question.

Independence and conflicts

Stated plainly, not buried in the letter

Scope: what this work is, and what it is not

A non-attest consulting engagement

A lender relies on the earnings figure to make a credit decision, so the character of the engagement belongs on the face of the page rather than only in the letter. A quality of earnings is a non-attest consulting engagement, performed under the AICPA Statement on Standards for Consulting Services (CS section 100). It is not an audit, a review, a compilation, an examination or any other attestation engagement, and it is not performed under the AICPA attestation standards. It gives no opinion or assurance.

Questions this desk is asked first

Four answers worth having before you call

The seller already has a quality of earnings. Can the lender use it?

No, on an Initial Acquisition or Business Expansion with a Business Purchase Price of $3 million or more. SOP 50 10 8.1 requires the QoE to be conducted for the benefit of the lender and bars a report prepared by or for the seller, however thorough it is (Appendix 15, C.1.i). It is still worth reading: it names the add-backs the seller believes in, which is where the testing starts.

Is a sell-side QoE a waste of money then?

Not if it is bought for what it does. It will not satisfy the lender. It will find the problems before a buyer's advisor does, at a stage where they can be fixed rather than priced. The free sale readiness check is the place to start, because it will tell a seller whether a paid sell-side QoE is premature.

What makes a schedule slip?

Bank statements, in almost every case: a missing month, or an account nobody mentioned. The cash proof cannot be built around a gap. The schedule runs from complete information for this reason, and the intake list above is published so the gap can be found before the engagement rather than during it.

Does the company have to use Baratelli Bankable?

No. Any accounting system works, the records are what get tested either way, and the fee is the same. Bankable is free, and a company that has run its loan-readiness screens arrives with the package already in the layout this desk asks for, which shortens the engagement but is not a condition of it.

Engage

Ask for the Delta Fastener sample report

The sample quality of earnings report and its workbook are available on request. Reading an actual deliverable is a better basis for a decision than reading a page about one.

Philip A. Baratelli
Owner, Baratelli Transaction Advisory, LLC
phil@baratelliinstitute.com
(561) 228-6123
baratelliinstitute.com

Email this desk Everything Transaction Advisory offers Free sale readiness check Free reading: due diligence
Contact the firm

Arrange a confidential consultation.

Call
(561) 228-6123
Email
phil@baratelliinstitute.com

Baratelli Transaction Advisory, LLC
700 S Rosemary Avenue, Suite 204
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401

Request a consultation

Tell us a little about what you need, and we will be in touch.

This page describes professional services and is orientation only: it is not legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice, not an engagement, and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Engagements arise under a signed engagement letter, which governs scope. A quality of earnings is a non-attest consulting engagement and is not an audit, review, compilation or attestation engagement under AICPA standards; no opinion is expressed on the financial statements. A quality of earnings is performed under the AICPA Statement on Standards for Consulting Services (CS section 100), and its procedures are not designed to detect fraud. SBA references cite SOP 50 10 8.1 (published September 25, 2026; effective October 1, 2026), Appendix 15; verify the current text for any specific file. © 2026 The Baratelli Institute.