THE BARATELLI INSTITUTE · Mentoring at Scale
★ Companion Tool From the Money Reality · Ch 9 Multi-Offer Comparison
MONEY REALITY · JOB OFFER COMPARATOR

Compare Offers on Total Comp, Not Just Salary

The $75K offer in Austin is not the same as the $90K offer in San Francisco. The $65K with 8% 401(k) match is not the same as the $72K with no match. This tool runs all three offers side-by-side on total economic value: salary + bonus + match + health + PTO + RSUs + commute + state-tax differential.

"Most candidates negotiate the salary number. The 401(k) match, the bonus structure, the equity grant, the relocation package: those are the lines they leave on the table."

Offer A

Company name
Base salary ($)
Target bonus (% of base)
Sign-on bonus ($)
401(k) match (% of base, max)
Health premium (your $/mo)
PTO days/year
RSU/equity grant ($/yr)
State tax rate (%)
Commute cost ($/mo)
Cost of living index

Offer B

Company name
Base salary ($)
Target bonus (% of base)
Sign-on bonus ($)
401(k) match (% of base, max)
Health premium (your $/mo)
PTO days/year
RSU/equity grant ($/yr)
State tax rate (%)
Commute cost ($/mo)
Cost of living index

Offer C (optional)

Company name
Base salary ($)
Target bonus (% of base)
Sign-on bonus ($)
401(k) match (% of base, max)
Health premium (your $/mo)
PTO days/year
RSU/equity grant ($/yr)
State tax rate (%)
Commute cost ($/mo)
Cost of living index

The honest comparison

The negotiation note: if Offer B wins on total comp but you'd rather take Offer A for non-financial reasons (team, mission, role): go back to Offer A's recruiter with this analysis and ask for the gap to be closed. Most recruiters can move salary 5-15%, sign-on bonus 50-100%, and PTO 1-2 weeks if asked. The negotiation is the day you have the most leverage you'll ever have at that company; use it.
From the Money Reality First Job Edition. Ch 4 (First Salaried Paycheck) and Ch 8 (Employer 401(k) Match Capture) feed into this comparator. The full negotiation walkthrough, what to ask for, when to ask, when to walk, is in the Athletes' Wealth Playbook (transferable principles to any white-collar first-offer negotiation).

Illustrative only. PTO valued at salary / 240 working days. Cost of living index normalized at 100 = national average; 135 means cost of living is 35% higher (e.g. SF, NYC, Boston). State tax is flat-rate approximation. RSUs valued at face; real value depends on stock performance and vesting. Commute cost includes gas + parking + wear; for transit users, use monthly pass. Sign-on bonus often carries a 12-24 month clawback if you leave early. Not financial / career advice; consider intangibles too.

WANT THE METHODOLOGY BEHIND THIS TOOL?
Read more in the Money Reality.
The tool gives you the answer. The guide gives you the argumentthe case law, the worked examples, the negotiation playbook, the cross-check tables, the exception cases.
The methodology behind this calculator is in Ch 9 Multi-Offer Comparison of the reference guide.
Read more in the Money Reality → Browse all 47 guides
Educational references and tools, not legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice, and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consult a qualified professional about your specific situation. © 2026 The Baratelli Institute.